Alex Rodriguez bowed out of baseball on Friday night, hitting a double. He was often infuriating but he was never boring
The sport of baseball has always been known for odd symmetries. Friday night, Alex Rodriguez played the last game of his career as a New York Yankee against the same team he played his first, the Tampa Bay Rays (he hit a double too). Fitting that this time his Yankees would leave the winners, and it couldnt have mattered more in the dugout or less in the standings.
Rodriguez is probably the most reviled US athlete of his generation, in any sport. Barry Bonds probably surpasses him, but Bonds started playing a decade earlier and by the end of Bondss career, A-Rod was giving him a run for his money. There are lots of reasons those who hated Rodriguez those who still hate Rodriguez will give for that: his offputting attitude, his arrogance, his inability to stay out of the tabloids, and of course, the steroids. These are just symptoms; external expressions of a root cause. People feel the way they feel about A-Rod, as intensely as they do, because of money and the morality behind it.
There is a distinction so ingrained in the way we talk about Rodriguez and his career that it almost feels strange to explicitly spell it out: while on paper Rodriguez made his MLB debut in 1994 for the Seattle Mariners and played 790 games over that seven season period, the real story of Alex Rodriguez the parable of the rise and fall of a superstar doesnt begin until 26 January 2001, when the 25-year-old shortstop signed a 10-year, $252m contract with the Texas Rangers. It was the largest free agent contract in major league history by a wide margin, and arguably it ruined Rodriguezs career.
Three years later, Alex Rodriguez came to the New York Yankees on a stormcloud; the disposition and disposal of his massive contract by the Rangers was the hottest topic of the winter of 2003, and it ended with everyone angry at Rodriguez: the Rangers and their fans because their team had gone nowhere over the first three seasons of Rodriguezs deal; the Mariners and their fans because Rodriguez left Seattle for that contract in the first place; the MLBPA because Rodriguez tried to renegotiate that contract in order to go to the Red Sox; the Red Sox and their fans because Rodriguez listened to the MLBPA when they told him in no uncertain terms that was not permissible; and the Yankees and their fans because they already had Derek Jeter, a shortstop they loved on the team, a guy they nicknamed the Captain, and three years earlier their new third baseman gave an Esquire interview in which he opined that the Captain had it easy and had never actually had to lead.
That anger would not abate. Rodriguez was merely the sixth-best third baseman in the majors in his first season in New York, which was unacceptable considering he was the reigning American League MVP and was being paid a kings fortune (you know, comparatively; the 2004 Yankees were a $182m enterprise). And 2004 was painful for Yankees fans for other reasons as well, though Rodriguez was hardly to blame for New Yorks implosion in the ALCS. He had an .895 OPS with 2 HR and 5 RBI that series. But most of that came in the Game 3 19-8 blowout when everyone was hitting, comes the reply from certain quarters. He disappeared after that. So did the rest of the Yankee lineup. Thats why they lost.
The next year Rodriguez was once again the MVP of the American League, by a wide margin on the stat sheet, if not on award voters ballots in 2005, baseball writers love affair with Bostons David Ortiz was beginning to blossom. The Yankees didnt win the World Series. In 2006, Rodriguez had another off year (for him): only a .914 OPS with 35 HR. The Yankees didnt win the World Series. In 2007, Rodriguez won his third and final American League MVP Award, this one pretty much uncontested. The Yankees, once again, did not win the World Series. This was a franchise whose fans were used to success not merely historically, but specifically and immediately. It had only been a few years since the Bronx Bombers won four world championships in five seasons, after all.
The Yankees were a good, solid playoff team in those years, if a bit inconsistent in the starting pitching and without a clear staff ace; but most good, solid playoff teams dont end up winning the World Series once, let alone multiple times the current San Francisco Giants dynasty being the modern exception that tests the rule. But this was about money, remember. By Opening Day of 2008, the Yankees were paying $209m for their roster. They expected that to buy them more than just a good, solid playoff team.
So who was to blame? Theres always so much to go around, when expectations have been frustrated: Randy Johnson took his fair share (yes, these were the Randy Johnson years in New York); Melky Cabrera, then in his early twenties and a well-regarded prospect, was unable to put together the success hed find later on elsewhere; first base was an underwhelming carousel of novelty guys, journeymen and Jason Giambi. But in the winter of 2007, one target dwarfed all the rest in ire: Alex Rodriguez, the reigning American League MVP. Why? How?
Because that damn contract of his had one last finger to curl shut, of course. Mere days after the Boston Red Sox swept the Colorado Rockies out of the World Series, A-Rod opted out.
Opt-out clauses are now almost boilerplate features of any massive free agent contract, but back at the turn of the century when Rodriguezs agent, Scott Boras, negotiated the 10-year deal with the Rangers they were fairly new territory. Starting in 2007, A-Rod had the contractual right to void the remainder of his deal in the ten days following the end of that years World Series, and thereby become a free agent.
Looking back, whats odd about that winter was how certain everyone was Rodriguez was leaving New York. Part of this was because thats what JD Drew had done when he similarly opted out of his Boras-negotiated contract with the Dodgers and went to the Red Sox the year before; part of it was because it was hard to imagine the unhappy (but productive) relationship between A-Rod and the Yankees going on any longer. The local media was thrilled, in that peculiar, angry, excited way columnists get when an ambiguous issue suddenly clarifies into a moral fable for example, here is Pete Abraham, then-Yankees beatwriter for The Journal News, propping up Ron Villone of all people as the Gallant to Rodriguezs free agent Goofus. The year Rodriguez won his third American League MVP Award, Ron Villone pitched 42.1 innings of 4.25 ERA baseball in middle relief and walked almost as many guys as he struck out. Weird thoughts.
Abraham wrote that blog in the first week of November; by the second week of December, Rodriguez had re-signed with the Yankees. His new deal capped a crazy five weeks or so for Yankees fans, appetites whetted but never satiated by the obsessive coverage every public statement, sourced, anonymous, or otherwise, was being parsed and reparsed, then parsed again, then turned into a conspiracy theory. This, not his performance on the field, was how the nation knew Alex Rodriguez: the endless story, the star consuming everything around him in the gravity well of his undeserved fortune and misapplied fame. The cautionary tale: Minnesota, Oakland, Pittsburgh, teach your children right. Dont let your prospects grow up to be A-Rod. As if they would be so lucky.
Alex Rodriguez has only signed four professional contracts in his career. The first was a three year deal with the Seattle Mariners after they took him first overall in the 1993 draft. The second was also with the Mariners, signed after the first expired, buying out the next four team-controlled years of his career. The third was that fateful January deal with the Texas Rangers. Then there was the contract he signed days before Christmas to stay in New York. That was his fourth, and Rodriguez intended for it to be his last. He not Boras negotiated the terms, as he took pains to make clear to the press. He wanted everyone to know that, as if somehow that was the thing that was going to make fans like him. Above all, he wanted to retire a Yankee. Last night, his wish was finally, brutally granted. It took the form of a mercy killing.
The fourth contract was ten years in length, just like the one that had preceded it, and was loaded with all sorts of synergistic, cross-promotional escalators and sidepots concocted with an eye towards the triumphal end of his Hall of Fame career. The centerpiece was a $30m marketing agreement based on reaching home run milestones; $6m apiece for reaching 660, 714, 755, 762, and 763. In 2008, these were not idle clauses; it seemed plausible if not probable that Rodriguez would end his career as the new Home Run King. In 2016, they seem not tragic but cruel; a mean-spirited joke Rodriguez played on his future self.
The history of this contract is far fresher, far more raw: after being the best hitter on a forgettable 2008 team that finished in third place and was most notable for giving 80 innings to Sidney Ponson, Rodriguez finally did it. In 2009, the New York Yankees won the World Series on the back of an amazing postseason performance by A-Rod: 68 PA of 1.308 OPS hitting, with 6 HR and 18 RBI. He won the Babe Ruth Award, making him the postseason MVP. That should have been it: that should have been the moment things changed for Alex Rodriguez in New York.
In another world, maybe they did. But in this one, shortly before the beginning of the 2009 season someone leaked a list of 104 players that had tested positive for performance-enhancing drugs in a supposedly sealed 2003 MLB fact-finding survey to Sports Illustrated. Rodriguezs name was on that list. He denied the allegations for two days, and on the third, he admitted to steroid use.
That was what the world took away from Rodriguezs year. Not the postseason heroics and not the World Series ring, but the money and the cheating. Without the money, the Yankees could have quietly forgiven the cheating, as they did with other players. Without the cheating, the Yankees would have been more than happy to spend the money. But both together made them look like fools that had overpaid a liar for a defective product.
That wasnt the end of A-Rod and PEDs; in 2013 hed be named as an offender in the Biogenesis investigation, a sloppy, ethically and legally compromised show trial that Major League Baseball inflicted on their product more as a means to expand the discretionary power of the Commissioners Office than as a good-faith effort to punish violations of the Joint Drug Agreement. As part of the Biogenesis fallout, Rodriguez would accept a one-year suspension for the 2014 season, despite not having failed a drug test. This was his nadir; at one point Rodriguez was not only suing MLB, but the Players Association as well, doing anything in his power to get a legal injunction to allow him to continue playing.
But it was three years earlier, in 2009, when Rodriguezs dream of a triumphal final season full of milestones, columnist hagiographies and pre-game farewells at visiting stadiums vanished. That was when the narrative surrounding his money and his morality suddenly clarified, his story arc was made legible, and it turned out he was not a hero, not even the flawed, Greek kind. Nor was he a villain, because villains have the power to do harm. Somehow the best baseball player of his generation was nothing more than an undignified fraud. That he was successful in spite of that became an embarrassment; his career was either a lie, a joke, or both, and the Yankees didnt want him to stick around for them to find out. They tried everything they could to get rid of him, but Rodriguez just kept showing up to work, eager to get out there and play; a ghost haunting Yankee Stadium, ignoring his own exorcism.
All of that is why a guy who was Rodriguezs clear inferior on his best day got to hit weak grounders at the top of the order for all of 2014, and A-Rod got a press conference, a week on the bench, one final out playing third base at Yankee Stadium and his unconditional release after the game. And you know what? He looked pretty goddamn happy with it.
His last game was won by Yankee heroics, but they were not his own. That didnt seem to affect his enjoyment of them. Jeters story ended in triumph; A-Rods ended with the acceptance of fate. Theres something more human about the latter than the former. Rodriguez is retiring to work with Yankees minor leaguers as a special instructor and advisor; thats something hes been doing for years informally, but has shown an especially keen interest in lately. Its work he seems well-suited for. It will keep him around a game he clearly loves, and an organization he clearly tries to love.
A-Rod can be baffling, infuriating, frustrating and mystifying in turn, but he is never tragic. Alex Rodriguez spent 22 years hitting baseballs better than just about anyone else alive, and along the way made a whole lot of money, alienated friends, lied, cheated, disappointed himself and others, filed lawsuits, got suspended, wonked out over swing mechanics, mentored rookies, became a father, never really figured out how to talk to the press, watched his mistakes close the door on his chance at history and then made his peace with walking away. It was a privilege to watch him play and to write about his career, and I will miss him dearly.
- This article was amended on Saturday 13 August to correct the details of JD Drews contract. Drew had opted out of his contract with the Los Angeles Dodgers and gone to Boston, not, as we had written, opted out of Boston and gone to Philly. This has now been changed.
Read more: https://www.theguardian.com/sport/blog/2016/aug/13/alex-rodriguez-final-game-new-york-yankees-mlb